Dividend vs capital gains is a contentious issue. The two terms are often used interchangeably, but they are not the same thing. Among others they have completely different tax implications. Both are popular choices for investors, however, there are some key differences that you should be aware of.
What is a Capital Gain?
A capital gain is increase in value of asset, such as a stock, bond, real estate or other investment. The capital gains are realized when the investor sells asset for a price higher than the purchase price. There are two different types of capital gains: long-term and short-term capital gains.
Long-term capital gains apply to assets that the investor owns for more than one year before it sells the assets. Short-term capital gains taxes accrue on assets owned less than a year prior to sale.
In contrast, a capital loss is a decrease in the value of asset. Capital losses are realized when the asset is sold for a price that is lower than the purchase price. Similarly to capital gains, the time period of investment can be long-term and short-term.
In summary, investors generate capital when the selling price is higher than the original purchase price. If you sell an asset for less than your basis, then you will have capital loss. It’s important to note that the capital gain or loss is unrealized until you sell the asset for either a price higher or lower than the original purchase price.
What is a Dividend?
The dividend is share of profit that a company pays to its shareholders, usually in proportion to the number of shares held. Paying dividends is one way that companies distribute profits to the owners of the company.
The stock dividend yield is the percentage of a company’s annual dividend payments to its share price. It is generally accepted that a stock dividend yield should be greater than zero, but less than the company’s long-term growth rate.
The decision of whether to pay a dividend is basically related to the performance of company. If a company is struggling financially, it may not pay a dividend to investors. Likewise, generally speaking, a company will not pay dividend to investors even if it has significant growth potential.
Dividends are portion of profits of a company in which you own shares. It’s essential to have in mind that not all companies offer regular dividend payments to investors. Equally important, dividend payments are not automatically determined. Investors would have to consider many financial factors such as debt, profitability and profit before investing.
Difference between Dividend vs Capital Gains
The main difference between dividend and capital gains is that a dividend is a payment made to the owner of stock. In contrast, the capital gain is the profit made when the sale price of an asset is higher than its purchase price.
In general, the tax charge is low in case of dividend, while the capital gains tax is high, but it depends on the investment conditions, which can be short-term or long-term. The dividend is portion of the company’s profit and distributed among the shareholders, while with capital investment, the value increases in the long term.
The investors have no influence on the dividend payment. However, the investor can control the capital gains by selling the asset at a time when price is high. Dividends provide steady income, while capital gains convert assets into cash.
Dividends require relatively less investment to buy shares, while capital gains require a large investment to achieve higher capital gains. Periodic dividends depend on corporate policy, while capital gains are only once-in-a-lifetime investment.
Taxation
Some people believe that the tax rates should be the same for both dividends and capital gains, while others believe that they should not be tax relevant at all.
The capital gains are tax based on whether they are seen as short-term or long-term holdings. Short-term gains are often taxable similarly to dividend income. For long-term capital gains, the tax rate kicks in after you sell an investment you have held for more than a year.
The tax is on the net capital gains for the year. Net capital gains look like subtracting capital losses from capital gains for the year.
Companies usually pay dividends in cash. However, they can also be in the form of property or stock. Dividends can be ordinary or qualified. Ordinary dividends are taxable and investors must declare it as income, but investors must pay for qualified dividends at a lower capital gains rate.
When a corporation returns capital to a shareholder, it’s not considered a dividend. It reduces the shareholder’s stock in the company. When a stock basis is reduced to zero through the return of capital, any non-dividend distribution is considered capital gains and will be taxed as such.
In conclusion, since dividends are usually low income, the taxation liability is relatively low in comparison with capital gains. That means dividends may provide a more favorable tax option over the long term.
Conclusion Dividend vs Capital Gains
Dividend vs capital gains are two ways to make income from investments. A capital gain is an increase in the value of an asset over time, while a dividend is a payment made to shareholders by their investment. Both are different forms of investing, but they have one thing in common: they are tools that help you generate income from your capital.
Related articles
You might also like to read these articles for more information: